2007

  • The Lucille Lortel Awards
    - Nomination: Outstanding Lead Actor (Guardians)
  • The Satellite Awards
    - Nomination: Best Actor in a Series, Comedy or Musical (Pushing Daisies)
  • The Golden Globe Awards
    - Nomination: Best Performance by an Actor in a Television Series - Musical or Comedy (Pushing Daisies)

2004

  • The 49th Annual Village Voice OBIE Awards
    - Nomination: Best Performance, Cast (Small Tragedy) WON!
  • The Lucille Lortel Awards
    - Nomination: Outstanding Lead Actor (Small Tragedy)

2003

  • The IFP Gotham Awards
    - Nomination: Breakthrough Performance (Soldier’s Girl) WON!
  • The Golden Globe Awards
    - Nomination: Best Actor in a Supporting Role - Series, Mini-Series or Television Movie (Soldier’s Girl)
  • The Independent Spirit Awards
    - Nomination: Best Actor (Soldier’s Girl)
  • The IPA Satellite Awards
    - Nomination: Actor, Mini-Series or TV Role (Soldier’s Girl)